Adultery is not a crime; Supreme Court scraps Section 497

DCW Chairperson condemns SC ruling on adultery calls it'anti-women decision

DCW Chairperson condemns SC ruling on adultery calls it'anti-women decision

The Supreme Court on Thursday pronounced a landmark ruling on adultery in India.

"It was an outdated law which should have been removed long back", said Rekha Sharma, chairwoman of the National Commission for Women, speaking about the law to Asian News International.

BJP spokesperson Nalin Kohli said that every judgement of the SC has to be welcomed because it becomes the law "which we all have to subscribe to".

Section 34 (d) grants the right of a married person to sue his/her spouse on the grounds of adultery, fornication, bigamy, rape or any other unnatural offence.

The Supreme Court has ruled that adultery is no longer a criminal act.

CJI Misra clarified that adultery remained a ground for civil issues, including dissolution of marriage.

The petition was brought by Kerala native Joseph Shine, who had urged the top court to re-examine the validity of section 497 owing to its implied gender bias. It's time to say that husband is not the master of wife.

In Pakistan, it is punishable by up to 25 years in prison while in Bangladesh - both formerly part of British India - men, but not women, can be jailed for five years. We argued that Section 198 of the Cr.P.C violated Article 14 of the Constitution of India because they fail the test of reasonable classification as they carve out arbitrary classifications in favor of the husband. He has presided over a bench that made privacy a fundamental right, and another that struck down a law allowing the Muslim practice of "instant" divorce a year ago, widely seen as improving the rights of Muslim women.

"By today decriminalising adultery completely I think this is something which is just going to add to the pain of women in our country", she said.

The section punished the man for having sex with the wife of another man.

"For a man to be convicted for adultery is very rare because the crime has to be proved conclusively beyond doubt in the court".

In Indonesia's ultraconservative Islamic Aceh province, men and women found guilty of adultery can be whipped 100 times with a cane in public. It should be also noted that many countries around the world also do not hold adultery as a crime.

In the United Kingdom, adultery is not a criminal offence and like many other countries, one of the main reasons given for divorce.

Earlier only a Christian man could file for divorce on the grounds of adultery. Numerous rulings are based on testimony heard earlier this year, but only released now.

Stability of marriages is not an ideal to be scorned.

"If adultery is not a crime, how is this woman even going to file a case against the husband who might desert or abandon her".

The court, rather patronisingly, described the plea as a "crusade by a woman against a woman".

Two different panels on law reforms in 1971 and 2003 recommended that women should also be prosecuted for the offence.

Recommended News

  • Sparks fly between Pogba and Mourinho on training ground

    Sparks fly between Pogba and Mourinho on training ground

    The exchange left Pogba with a quizzical expression and he proceeded to walk past his coach offering further observations. While the first season on the field was uneven, the relationship between the two, at least front-facing, seemed O.K.
    'Rather Lenient': Judge Napolitano Weighs in on Bill Cosby's Prison Sentencing

    'Rather Lenient': Judge Napolitano Weighs in on Bill Cosby's Prison Sentencing

    Cliff Huxtable", Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin Steele said at a news conference, referring to Cosby's best-known role. For one, the #MeToo movement had been unleashed, toppling bad-behaving men whose abuse had previously been kept secret.
    Syria to get S-300 anti-air missiles from Russia: minister

    Syria to get S-300 anti-air missiles from Russia: minister

    Putin told Netanyahu that the measures had been taken to prevent any threat to Russian troops in Syria . President Donald Trump and Egypt's President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, among numerous others.
  • Versace rumoured to be Going on Sale soon

    Versace rumoured to be Going on Sale soon

    Models present creations at the Versace show during Milan Fashion Week Spring 2019 in Milan, Italy, September 21, 2018. Serving as the artistic director and vice-president of the group, she has called a staff meeting in Milan for Tuesday.
    Space hoppers hitch ride on an asteroid

    Space hoppers hitch ride on an asteroid

    The cautious announcement came after a similar JAXA probe in 2005 released a rover which failed to reach its target asteroid . Ryugu is a particularly primitive variety, and studying it could shed light on the origin and evolution of our own planet.
    European Union  to SNUB Trump and continue trading with Tehran

    European Union to SNUB Trump and continue trading with Tehran

    The Trump administration also accused Iran of promoting worldwide terrorism, which has been defiantly denied by Tehran . Trump said in July that he was ready to meet Rouhani without preconditions to negotiate a new deal.
  • New bombshell allegations against US Supreme Court nominee

    New bombshell allegations against US Supreme Court nominee

    But after more allegations emerged, some Republican senators have admitted that much is riding on his performance. Ford said Judge was laughing and playing loud music as Kavanaugh pinned her down on a bed and groped her.
    Wenger was more anxious  about playing style than winning: Cech

    Wenger was more anxious about playing style than winning: Cech

    I am of course talking about Dominic Calvert-Lewin's early chance, which was coolly swept away by the long legs of Cech. Philosophy: Arsenal goalkeeper Petr Cech and manager Arsene Wenger holding the 2017 Community Shield.
    Bale lauds 'unbelievable' Modric after FIFA Best triumph

    Bale lauds 'unbelievable' Modric after FIFA Best triumph

    Mohamed Salah's curling effort against Everton won that award. "Of course I would change everything to have won in Russian Federation ".
  • Iran says Trump is why oil prices are now so high

    The WTI Crude Oil market rallied during trading on Tuesday, but it seems to be struggling with the idea of $73 a barrel. Richard Robinson, manager of the Ashburton Global Energy Fund, said higher prices are nearly certainly on the cards.

    People everywhere walk out in solidarity with sexual assault survivors

    Kavanaugh will address allegations of sexual assault/misconduct made by former Yale classmate Deborah Ramirez , and by Dr. A request for comment to Charles Grassley, the chair of the Judiciary Committee was not immediately returned.
    Tiger Woods Wins First Golf Tournament Since 4 Back Surgeries

    Tiger Woods Wins First Golf Tournament Since 4 Back Surgeries

    That was when he was regularly winning multiple times every season, compiling trophies at a rate never before seen in golf. His victory at the Tour Championship puts to rest any concerns that he'd forgotten how to win.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.