Ohio's voter purge may be legal, but it's also voter suppression

Oral argument in the Ohio voter purge case brought out protesters in January

Oral argument in the Ohio voter purge case brought out protesters in January

The court's conservative majority ruled 5-4 that OH did not violate federal laws by purging voters who don't vote and fail to return notices confirming their residency.

The justices rejected arguments that practices by Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted violate a federal law meant to increase the ranks of registered voters. OH defended its practice by citing a provision of the 1993 National Voter Registration Act that states can remove potential voters from their lists and cancel registrations if they move. He's joined by four conservative colleagues, while all four liberal justices dissented. And, if that "one" consists of a failure to vote, then Ohio's program also fails to make the requisite "reasonable effort" to comply with subsection (a)'s statutory mandate.

Civil-rights groups say the case is a landmark in the larger attempt by conservative states to marginalize ethnic minorities, who tend to have fewer people registered to vote already.

Taken as a whole, this welter of provisions could plausibly be read in the way Justice Samuel Alito does on behalf of the Courts' Republicans - as an instruction manual to carry out the sort of voter purge that OH used in this case. The state appealed to the Supreme Court.

According to the 5-4 ruling, the state's "supplemental process" does not violate the National Voter Registration Act. "The Trump campaign reelection strategy is voter suppression", former Missouri Secretary of State Jason Kander (D), who runs the voting rights group Let America Vote, told The Hill.

"As expressly permitted by federal law", Alito said, OH "removes registrants only when they have failed to vote and have failed to respond to a change-of-residence notice".

In his own statement, Husted said he hoped the ruling would give other states a path toward purging duplicate or obsolete registrations.

The U.S. Supreme Court backed OH in its ruling on Monday regarding the state's current measure for canceling inactive voter registrations. "Ohio simply treats the failure to return a notice and the failure to vote as evidence that a registrant has moved, not as a ground for removal". Clyde said the process leads to the removal of eligible voters, and it's not necessary for the state to maintain accurate voter rolls.

Justice Sotomayor, in addition to joining the main dissent, also wrote separately to emphasize how voter purge schemes like Ohio's have a disproportionate impact on low-income voters and minority voters.

Reminder: In #Husted, the Department of Justice under Jeff Sessions made a decision to abandon its longstanding position that the National Voter Registration Act and the Help America Vote Act prohibit techniques like Ohio's voter purge.

OH voters who do not return the card and fail to vote in any election for four more years are presumed to have moved and are removed from the rolls, Alito wrote.

Alito responded: "Justice Sotomayor's dissent says nothing about what is relevant in this case - namely, the language of the NVRA", adding that she "has not pointed to any evidence in the record that OH instituted or has carried out its program with discriminatory intent". He voted in the 2004 and 2008 presidential elections but did not vote in 2012, saying he was unimpressed by the candidates.

The Trump administration supported Ohio's voter purge. "It does not", Alito said.

"No other state has a practice as ham-handed and draconian as Ohio's", the League of Women Voters argued in a brief in the case.

The case came about when Larry Harmon challenged the process arguing that he was removed from the rolls even though he had not moved, but rather had opted not to vote in 2009 and 2010.

Recommended News

  • With Tony for 'The Band's Visit,' Ari'el Stachel Embraces His Roots

    With Tony for 'The Band's Visit,' Ari'el Stachel Embraces His Roots

    According to the Tony Awards' website, Bruce Springsteen will also make a rare appearance with a performance during the show. Many critics have tapped The Band's Visit as their odds-on favourite to be crowned best new musical.
    Cuba releases details of mysterious health incident involving U.S

    Cuba releases details of mysterious health incident involving U.S

    Those affected have suffered a range of symptoms including hearing loss, dizziness, fatigue, cognitive issues and sleep loss. There is a USA medical team in Guangzhou assessing whether more people need to leave China, the Associated Press reported .
    USA  reaches new settlement with China's ZTE

    USA reaches new settlement with China's ZTE

    US Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross defended the new agreement, saying in a statement: "We will closely monitor ZTE's behavior". USA goods exported to China a year ago totaled US$130 billion while Chinese imports to the USA totaled US$506 billion.
  • Skyrim Very Special Edition is Real and Out for Amazon Echo

    Skyrim Very Special Edition is Real and Out for Amazon Echo

    Once the Skill is linked to your device, you then say "Alexa, Open Skyrim " and the quest starts. It's all fun and games, until you realise you can actually play Skyrim: Very Special Edition .
    Jamie Dimon, Warren Buffett urge CEOs to end quarterly earnings forecasts

    Jamie Dimon, Warren Buffett urge CEOs to end quarterly earnings forecasts

    Securities laws require quarterly reports on profits, revenue and other information but do not require quarterly forecasts. Dimon credited him with doing the "heavy lifting" for the search.
    Trump arrives in Quebec for G7 summit, wants Russian Federation  invited back

    Trump arrives in Quebec for G7 summit, wants Russian Federation invited back

    That move was met with criticism at home, including from Republicans , and announcements of retaliatory tariffs from USA allies. Canada hosts this year's G7 in La Malbaie , Quebec. "And we have many deals like that", Trump said, according to PTI.
  • What if Lebron James goes to Boston?

    What if Lebron James goes to Boston?

    Other possible destinations are the Boston Celtics , the San Antonio Spurs , the Miami Heat and dare I say it, the Warriors . Whatever is next, James said his family will play a major role. "I let the emotions get the best of me".
    Authorities identify woman bitten by alligator

    Authorities identify woman bitten by alligator

    The alligator is believed to have dragged 47-year-old Shizuka Matsuki into a lake while she was walking her dogs Friday afternoon. It said the Commission will be conducting a thorough investigation into the incident, but didn't provided additional details.
    Hawaii volcano: Kilauea crater rocked by 5.5 magnitude quake

    Hawaii volcano: Kilauea crater rocked by 5.5 magnitude quake

    Since May 3rd, Kilauea's lava, ash and rocks have destroyed about 600 homes, closed major highways and prompted health warnings. Lava from a fissure near the volcano spewed into Kapoho Bay forcing billowing clouds of steam into the atmosphere.
  • England arrive! Three Lions rock up at Repino hotel for World Cup

    England arrive! Three Lions rock up at Repino hotel for World Cup

    Southgate revealed Rashford will be assessed by medical staff, but is confident the injury is not too serious. We've counted down the weeks and now only days remain before England take to the field at the 2018 World Cup .
    Must-Read Facts on New York Times Reporter Ali Watkins

    Must-Read Facts on New York Times Reporter Ali Watkins

    The indictment alleges Watkins and Wolfe spoke on the phone for about seven minutes shortly after the piece was published. Wolfe, a former Army intelligence analyst, stopped performing committee work in December and retired in May.
    White House: 'Vast Majority' Of Eagles Have 'Abandoned Their Fans'

    White House: 'Vast Majority' Of Eagles Have 'Abandoned Their Fans'

    Trump disinvited the Eagles from their planned visit after it became clear that most members of the team were not going to attend. Most players (and there were many players, many players.) that wanted to opt out had decided long b4 the anthem rule came down.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.